By Benjamin Dangl
Toward Freedom
July 7th, 2011
Reviewed: Crossing the American Crises: From Collapse To Action, A Documentary Film by Sílvia Leindecker and Michael Fox. Published by PM Press/Estreito Meios Productions.
When
the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression hit the US on
September 15, 2008, filmmakers Sílvia Leindecker and Michael Fox began a
journey across the country to see how the economy was impacting
people’s lives. Their interviews, which span two years and nearly 40
states, draw from farmers, truck drivers, homeless people, workers,
immigrants and more. The result is the documentary Crossing the American Crises: From Collapse To Action, a film full of desperation, hope and grassroots solutions.
Leindecker
and Fox are the makers of the earlier documentary Beyond Elections:
Redefining Democracy in the Americas, and Fox was an editor of the book
Venezuela Speaks!: Voices From The Grassroots. Like these earlier works,
Crossing the American Crises highlights the voices of people participating in grassroots activism and everyday struggles for a better world.
The
first stop of their trip is Detroit, where the camera cuts to empty
store fronts and factories. “Detroit is what it is because of industry
and the industrial revolution, and capitalism, and so-called democracy
and how all those failed. And this is what we have left with it,” Jon
Blount of the activist collective Detroit Summer tells Leindecker and
Fox. Such bits of hard-won insight from streets, factory floors and
living rooms across America are interspersed throughout the film.
The
next visit is to the Rosebud Lakota Indian Reservation in South Dakota,
where they speak with Alfred Bone Shirt. “We’re seeing that there’s a
segment of our society that feel we’re left out, neglected, abused;
rights are violated. We’re in a depression down here so bad that people
just wanna give up.” His words are underscored by footage of the
reservation itself, a place crushed by economic depression.
After
stops in Utah, Oakland and Los Angeles, they head out onto Route 66,
where, Fox tells the camera they want to “see the direct effects on the
local community.” And indeed, that is what they find at nearly every
stop in their tour; very real life stories of how the US economy is
making life difficult for people from coast to coast and everywhere in
between.
In New Orleans, they speak with people in the Lower 9th
Ward, a neighborhood that was destroyed by Katrina in 2005. Robert Green
and his family lived in this community for 38 years before Katrina hit,
and at the time of the shooting of the film they were still living in a
FEMA trailer. Green is interviewed with his daughter and wife next to a
string of empty lots—places where his neighbors’ homes used to be
located before the storm destroyed them.
Fox asks Green what he
thinks about the government bailout, the major issue of the day. Green
tells him, “It’s ironic that it only took [the government] two weeks to
issue a $700 billion check. It took them three years after Katrina and
this is what you see.” He pointed to the empty lots, saying the names of
the families that used to live there. “So basically every house, every
family that’s gone actually was a family that should be here now. And if
they would have been given the money in two weeks like the way they did
in Congress, the way they did in Wall Street, then every last one of
these families would have rebuilt their houses, and this whole Gulf
Coast area would have been rebuilt because everybody in the Gulf Coast
is basically like the people down here: family first.”
This story
conveys a sentiment shared by many of the interviewees in this film:
outrage at the disparity between the government’s concern for Wall
Street over the people bearing the everyday grind of the crisis.
Crossing the American Crises
then turns to the hope people felt in the election of Barack Obama in
2008. Yet after the election, the camera cuts to a stream of grim
economic news, and stories of people struggling to make ends meet. One
college graduate appearing in the film went through 109 job interviews
before finally finding a very low-paying position at Staples. A homeless
man on the Gulf Coast tells Fox and Leindeker he’ll ask them for money
after the interview so he can get some lunch.
On a cold, snowy
street corner in New York City, they interview John Lambertus, a
homeless man who lost his job in May of 2008 and couldn’t find new work.
Lambertus points to a plastic bag he’s carrying, saying, “You see this?
This is my blanket, another jacket in case this one gets messed up, and
another pair of pants—and that’s my situation.” He worked in a printing
press for thirty years before losing his job. “I’ll be 51 in April and
I’m in the street,” he says, the cold wind thundering against the
microphone.
So what is to be done with all of this bleak news from the American crises? That leads to the second part of the film: Action. Crossing the American Crises
goes on to include many solutions to these economic and social
problems, focusing on inspiring stories of grassroots alternatives and
responses.
There is the Vermont Workers’ Center fighting for
affordable healthcare for all, the Green Worker Cooperative in the Bronx
that sells recycled building materials, the Santa Fe Alliance in New
Mexico advocating for local producers and businesses over tax-dodging
multinational chains, and the Iraq Veterans Against the War struggling
for veterans’ benefits. There are stories of people working for
affordable housing, jobs, better working conditions, improved public
transportation and prison justice.
These groups are largely led
by the people who are impacted the most by these various crises.
Organizers are meeting these challenges in states across the country.
“Organizing is the key! Organizing is the key!” JoAnn Watson from the
Detroit Council tells a boisterous crowd at the US Social Forum in her
city.
Alongside these stories of hopeful organizing is a vision
for a better world. “The people have to act through their own
organizations to implement their vision of what life should be like,”
explains Kathleeen Cleaver, a law professor at Yale University.
That’s
a central message of this film – that when the politicians, banks,
bosses and economy fail to work for the people, it’s the people that
have to form the backbone of movements for economic justice, peace and
equality and rights. In the midst of these crises, those movements are
already thriving across the US today.
As Robert Green from the
Lower 9th Ward says, “Basically, we need to start taking back our
government, taking back our taxes, start taking back our control from
our elected officials because they’re not putting us first.”
Such insight from people across the country makes Crossing the American Crises
an impressive film that captures the spirit of America today. Its
stories of human hardship, solidarity and hope paint a portrait of
America that is both heart-breaking and inspiring. This documentary is a
powerful reminder of the countless social movements working each day to
transform this country, from the fields of Oklahoma to the streets of
New Orleans.
***
Benjamin Dangl is the author of the new book Dancing with Dynamite: Social Movements and States in Latin America (AK
Press). He edits TowardFreedom.com, a progressive perspective on world
events, and UpsideDownWorld.org, a website on activism and politics in
Latin America. Email Bendangl(at)gmail(dot)com.
