By Charlie Allison & Gillian Daniels
1. How did you come to write horror–you seem to have written a lot in that genre according to your bio. And while we’re talking horror, is there something about it that sets it apart for you?
It took me a while to admit to myself I was a horror writer! I kept going toward dark fantasy and themes in my work, though. My first professionally published poem, “Eat the Children,” is from 2013 in Andromeda Spaceways Inflight Magazine and is about fairy tale tropes and the cruelty of predators. I should have realized! In my defense, horror is only sort of its own genre. It can be appended to science fiction, drama, thriller, anything. It’s more of a set of feelings and fears, extreme scenarios and how we react to them. I appreciate that versatility.
2.How did you choose/happen upon Jenny Greenteeth as a subject for your first novel?
I actually wrote and submitted two complete novels to agents years before JENNY. The first was a YA novel I started when I was a teenager myself. It was about Puck from A Midsummer Night’s Dream meeting and falling in love with a human girl. I think I started sending it out during the peak saturation point of YA supernatural romance! Even as a finished novel, it was very rough regarding the plot. These days, I think of it more as a novel that taught me to write. Some DNA carried over into JENNY WILL EAT YOU NOW, though, particularly the idea of a mythological creature becoming entangled with a human! Also, I’ll always appreciate the trickster energy of Puck and hope to infuse it into other works I do.
3. I love the idea of any-Puck forward media and tricksters in general! So its fair to say was a meandering path to Jenny Greenteeth, then. I don’t think it’s a spoiler to say that water is major connective bit of tissue through the novel both for plot and imagery–Jenny starts the novel living under a sealed train station in Boston–and as she grows throughout the novel, the sort of water she’s exposed to and seeks out changes. Was this a deliberate authorial choice?
Yes, Jenny experiencing new and different bodies of water as she becomes more in touch with the contemporary world felt super important! Early on in the novel, she seeks out a cenote, which is a sort of cave or sink hole with water inside it. Because they’re mostly in the Yucatán, they’re associated with Mayan culture and stories of the afterlife. They’re a subterranean, surreal, liminal space, a sort of natural location for a mythical creature who doesn’t fit. As the novel continues, we find that Jenny can also go to bodies of water that are man-made. I think this novel is a love story between two people but it’s also a love story between an alienated individual and the rest of society.
4. There’s an old saw that ‘horror is political’ circling about the internet–do you agree? As a horror writer, do you think there is liberatory potential in horror tales or horror discourse more generally?
Absolutely! Horror is political. I also think that all fiction, even the most banal stories, are political in the sense that they always have political context. Where a story is made and who has the privilege to tell and enjoy it, for example, is worth studying. Certainly, I’m a white American female with a college degree and it hasn’t escaped my notice that I’ve encountered a lot of people in trade publishing who look like me and come from a similar background. That’s political!
I think horror as a genre is more likely than most to engage in ideas around justice and morality. Who’s allowed to seek justice? Who gets to decide what justice is? Why care about justice for other people? Jenny is a character who initially believes she’s allowed to kill whoever and however many people she likes. She’s hungry and humans are food. It makes it impossible for her to function in a broader social structure. As she begins to make new choices and develop a little more empathy, that belief in her inherent value over humans is tested. I enjoyed writing a character learning that maybe, just maybe, people deserve to be viewed and judged as individuals
5. It’s interesting you mention how alienated Jenny is at the novel’s beginning. This is kinda a gimme question since we were on a panel about Cannibalism in Fiction at this year’s Readercon, but could you talk about the relationship between alienation, cannibalism and the use of cannibalism by some (usually imperialist and aggressively hierarchal) cultures to denote otherness and sub-humanity (both in history and fantasy)?
Cannibalism is a great metaphor in general and can contain so many different meanings. I think it can be a way to explore Jenny’s sense of self as she often claims to be a “superior” being but is, in fact, more of a bottom feeder. Her sense of self is hierarchical. Though Jenny says she pities humans, they’re critical to her sense of pride. She maintains herself by turning others into food, her sole power coming from her ability to assert her desires and autonomy over others.
But cannibalism is also a helpful metaphor for intimacy. It’s “carnal desire” at its most literal! It’s the only way she knows how to connect without developing empathy. By consuming a man she lusts after, Jenny makes this person a part of herself, but it also ignores his autonomy and personhood. She sees humans as objects but has to learn to see at least one of them as a person in order to leave her insular life behind.
5a. Was that something that organically appeared with the character of Jenny Greenteeth or was it something that emerged through subsequent draft as a major theme in the novel?
This philosophy behind why Jenny wants to feed was extremely important to the novel. Did all of the political stuff I thought about come through? Like how lack of empathy turns people into monsters? Maybe, but honestly, at the end of the day, I just enjoyed telling the story.
5b. What text or media did you find really helpful or entertaining as you wrote JENNY WILL EAT YOU NOW?
Get ready. I became obsessed with finding similar media while working on this project.
There’s some great themes exploring womanhood and alienation in Under the Skin, both the Michel Faber sci-fi novel and the much more existential, moody 2013 film by Jonathan Glazer. The woman creature who wanders around has a character arc similar to Jenny’s: she starts outside of humanity and realizes she has the option to become a part of it even if all humans won’t exactly like her back.
For “horror romance” fans, Helpmeet by Naben Ruthnum rocked me. Just a wonderful story about intimacy, love, and the mess of caring for others.
For a classic in female alienation, I absolutely recommend Shirley Jackson’s We Have Always Lived in the Castle, and in a similar if more brutal vein, I found a lot of inspiration in the disturbed teenage main character Pauline from Excision (2012).
I would be remiss if I didn’t mention mermaid media! Jenny Greenteeth is sort of their mythological cousin, after all. This includes the murdering mermaid Polish musical, The Lure (2015) directed by Agnieszka Smoczyńska. It has so much of the camp and high emotion I wanted to give Jenny Will Eat You Now.
For a water creature heroine who’s a social misfit because she’s sexually active and flirty rather than murderous, Miranda (1948) surprised me with how fun and funny it is. Glynis Johns, who’s best remembered as being the suffragette mother in Mary Poppins (1964), is so utterly charming as a man-crazy mermaid. As a note, I recommend completely ignoring the sequel to Miranda called Mad About Men (1954) which has a high rating across review websites because I think its data was mashed with the TV show Mad Men over on imdb at some point.
I of course thought about Shape of Water in all its aquatic, pulp-fiction beauty. Guillermo del Toro did a great job with the romance there particularly once I saw The Creature from the Black Lagoon series and realized he’s taking that mid-century science fiction language to comment on social structure. I’d also like to add that he collaborated on a novel adaption with Pulitzer prize winner Daniel Kraus which I think is worth a look.
9. That’s a wonderful amount of research for this book! It looks like you really had a lot of fun with the research process. So much of JENNY WILL EAT YOU NOW involves change and growth–on my second read through I thought of the zine ‘How to Write A Fascist Character’, in that Jenny slowly transitions from an alienated, lonely figure convinced of her superiority to humans, to something much different through exposure to others and other ways of seeing. You touched on this in a previous question, but is it possible to read this horror/romance as also a kind of deprogramming of prejudice/fascism/alienation narrative as well?
Oh man, that list of work is the tip of the iceberg. An Encyclopedia of Fairies: Hobgoblins, Brownies, Bogies, and Other Supernatural Creatures by Katharine Briggs was a book I encountered and read long before I conceived of the novel. When I was in Scotland years ago, I picked up The Enchantment of the Trossachs: Some Fairy Traditions of the District Published for the Tercentenary Of the Spiriting Away of Robert Kirk by Louis Stott. In the latter, “Faun” is defined as a “Rural God with the horns and legs of a goat (Classical) […] Kirk defines Fauns as a rank of Demon betwixt Angels and Men.” Obviously, she had to become a character!
And yes, I’m so happy I was able to communicate Jenny’s shift in thinking. There’s definitely some re-programming happening for her. I thought about her character arc as the path of someone who starts firmly in authoritarian ideology, specifically “might = (I’m) right,” moving toward embracing community and the collective good. In a sense, I think she begins as a “lean-in girl boss corporate ‘feminist'” who believes she she should only rely on herself and ends up steering toward collectivism where she’s learned to at least recognize the individual value of other people! She’s not a paragon of morality at the end of the book, of course, and I can see her easily slipping back into old habits one day. Learning to love can be revolutionary but it’s not the be all and end all of revolution! Still, I do think she’s moved a bit in the way she views humanity and how she sees herself among them.
10. Final question! What’s next for you, what projects are you excited about?
Oh man. I wrote one book and now I have to do it all again?!
In all seriousness, I have a couple pitches I’m working on that I want to send around for some feedback. Nothing to announce at the moment! Right now, I’ve been thinking a lot about the gothic genre, the limits of dark humor, and how violence can be enormously funny when it’s not happening to you or someone with whom you empathize. Critique groups and the input of others, including my literary agent, were vital in creating this novel, so I’m curious to see who I can pull into the next journey with me!
Charlie Allison is a writer, researcher, and storyteller based in Philadelphia. Charlie has worked as a gardener, tutor to children with learning disabilities, an English teacher, chess instructor, and as a bureaucrat. He has published short stories in Pickman’s Press, Podcastle, and Sea Lion Press. He currently runs his own website at charlie-allison.com, where the genesis for this book was formed as a series of YouTube videos with the help of Sewer Rats Productions. He is active in the Philadelphia storytelling and mutual aid communities. Charlie is frequently bullied by his cat in the small hours of the morning.
Gillian Daniels’ poetry and short fiction have appeared in more than thirty publications. She writes, works, and haunts the streets in the Greater Boston area of Massachusetts. She can be found on Instagram and Bsky as @gillianlynndaniels and on gilliandaniels.site. Jenny Will Eat You Now is her debut novel.


